Ladia's avatar
Ladia

April 5, 2021

0
The Favourite Movie

Note: The journal is aiming for a formal tone.

No week goes by without me watching a movie. There are periods in which I watch movies more often and other times when I forget about them because I am occupied with work. Sometimes after watching a movie, I feel bad for the time I could have spent more wisely. However, they helped me improve my English substantially. I even watched some of them multiple times, for example, the series of Harry Potter films.

They are based on books written by J. K. Rowling. The first book, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, was published in 1997. Since then, more than 500 million copies of these books have been sold, making it the best-selling book series in history. It has been translated into more than 80 languages making it popular all around the world.

The main character is Harry Potter—a young wizard. He and his friends attend a wizarding school learning everything about witchcraft and wizardry. Throughout the series, they experience the return of the dark wizard, Lord Voldemort, against whom and his followers they are trying to fight.

The wizarding world in both books and films gained lots of fans throughout the years and does not seem to be getting any less popular. Some people like books more because the story is more detailed. On the other hand, the films provide a lively experience. Even though everybody has their preference, I can recommend both.

challengeformal
Corrections

The Favourite Movie

We expect "My" or "His" or "Their" or something like that here. Choosing "The" has a strange effect, perhaps making it sound as the movie itself is really the focus and it doesn't matter whose favourite it is - simply that it IS a favourite.

Note: Theis journal is aiming for a formal tone.

No week goes by without me watching a movie.

I don't know if this is ungrammatical, but it feels... loose. More formally, I'd expect this to be closer to "Not a week goes by where I don't watch a movie." Or "in which".

Some people might think movie itself is quite an informal word, but I don't think it matters very much.

There are periods in which I watch movies more often, and other times when I forget about them because I am occupied with work.

It would read better to keep the same noun on each side of the "and other" here. "periods in which ... and other periods when", or just "and others when". But I think this is okay.

Sometimes, after watching a movie, I feel bad forabout the time I could have spent more wisely.

I think "feel bad for" is most natural either as "I feel bad for [some entity that I pity]" or "I feel bad for not spending my time more wisely" - with a gerund, something you did that you regret. Here, "about" works better.

Comma at the start because this is a dependent clause. The sentence is "Sometimes I feel bad ...", and you have embedded "after watching a movie" inside it.

However, they helped me improve my English substantially.

If watching movies no longer helps your English, or you no longer watch movies, this is fine. Otherwise, it's an ongoing process and it's present perfect "they have helped me".

I even watched some of them multiple times, for example, the series of Harry Potter films.

Again, if you wanted to keep the sense of movie-watching being something you do as an ongoing process, "I have even watched".

They are based on books written by J. K. Rowling.

The first book, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, was published in 1997.

Since then, more than 500 million copies of these books have been sold, making it the best-selling book series in history.

It has been translated into more than 80 languages, making it popular all around the world.

The main character is Harry Potter—a young wizard.

He and his friends attend a wizarding school, learning everything about witchcraft and wizardry.

Throughout the series, they experience the return of the dark wizard, Lord Voldemort, against whom and hiswhose followers they are trying to fight.

This is an interesting way to try saying this :) It's the kind of thing you say to show off how well you write. I'm not actually sure my suggestion is permissible - it might need to be "against whom and against whose followers".

It may be the best way to say it, I can't think of a formula that preserves all the meaning without being cumbersome. The closest I can get is "They try to fight against Voldemort and his followers, but throughout the series they experience his return." Not exactly the same emphasis, but something you can say without thinking so hard about it.

The wizarding world, in both books and films, gained lots of fans throughout the years, and does not seem to be getting any less popular.

"in both books and films" is again a dependent clause, and the other comma I put in because it just feels like an appropriate place for one. There's probably a rule about it.

Some people like the books more because the story is more detailed.

"Some people like books more" - books *in general*. Some people like books more, while others prefer films or TV. No specific books.

On the other hand, the films provide a lively experience.

Even though everybody has their preference, I can recommend both.

Feedback

Really strong writing!

Ladia's avatar
Ladia

April 5, 2021

0

I'm impressed! This must be the best correction I've ever received! I can't believe this is free. Thanks a lot!

Ladia's avatar
Ladia

April 5, 2021

0

No week goes by without me watching a movie.

What might be a good alternative for "movie"? I used "film" and "movie" interchangeably in this journal without even knowing it. However, I'm more inclined to write "movie" because I'm influenced by American English. Are there any situations in which it's preferred to use one over the other?

secretpostman's avatar
secretpostman

April 5, 2021

0

If I charged I'd have to actually learn the rules about where to put commas :)

I don't think there are really any good synonyms other than film. In super formal contexts like award shows they're sometimes called "motion pictures", but most of the time that would be weird. In serious writing I'd personally prefer film over movie, but it's hardly an absolute rule. In fact, it might just be a Britishism. I'd probably start out with "film" and eventually have to use "movie" once I got tired of repeating myself!

I guess sometimes you can use the genre of the film as a synonym. "the drama", "the comedy", "the documentary", "the horror" and so on. I don't know if you could do that with Harry Potter, really.

Ladia's avatar
Ladia

April 5, 2021

0

Agreed. It'd be awkward to say "the drama" with Harry Potter. If I could introduce the movie as a drama first, then it would make sense. But it may come in handy some time!

The Favourite Movie


The Favourite Movie

We expect "My" or "His" or "Their" or something like that here. Choosing "The" has a strange effect, perhaps making it sound as the movie itself is really the focus and it doesn't matter whose favourite it is - simply that it IS a favourite.

Note: The journal is aiming for a formal tone.


Note: Theis journal is aiming for a formal tone.

No week goes by without me watching a movie.


No week goes by without me watching a movie.

I don't know if this is ungrammatical, but it feels... loose. More formally, I'd expect this to be closer to "Not a week goes by where I don't watch a movie." Or "in which". Some people might think movie itself is quite an informal word, but I don't think it matters very much.

There are periods in which I watch movies more often and other times when I forget about them because I am occupied with work.


There are periods in which I watch movies more often, and other times when I forget about them because I am occupied with work.

It would read better to keep the same noun on each side of the "and other" here. "periods in which ... and other periods when", or just "and others when". But I think this is okay.

Sometimes after watching a movie, I feel bad for the time I could have spent more wisely.


Sometimes, after watching a movie, I feel bad forabout the time I could have spent more wisely.

I think "feel bad for" is most natural either as "I feel bad for [some entity that I pity]" or "I feel bad for not spending my time more wisely" - with a gerund, something you did that you regret. Here, "about" works better. Comma at the start because this is a dependent clause. The sentence is "Sometimes I feel bad ...", and you have embedded "after watching a movie" inside it.

However, they helped me improve my English substantially.


However, they helped me improve my English substantially.

If watching movies no longer helps your English, or you no longer watch movies, this is fine. Otherwise, it's an ongoing process and it's present perfect "they have helped me".

I even watched some of them multiple times, for example, the series of Harry Potter films.


I even watched some of them multiple times, for example, the series of Harry Potter films.

Again, if you wanted to keep the sense of movie-watching being something you do as an ongoing process, "I have even watched".

They are based on books written by J. K. Rowling.


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

The first book, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, was published in 1997.


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

Since then, more than 500 million copies of these books have been sold, making it the best-selling book series in history.


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

It has been translated into more than 80 languages making it popular all around the world.


It has been translated into more than 80 languages, making it popular all around the world.

The main character is Harry Potter—a young wizard.


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

He and his friends attend a wizarding school learning everything about witchcraft and wizardry.


He and his friends attend a wizarding school, learning everything about witchcraft and wizardry.

Throughout the series, they experience the return of the dark wizard, Lord Voldemort, against whom and his followers they are trying to fight.


Throughout the series, they experience the return of the dark wizard, Lord Voldemort, against whom and hiswhose followers they are trying to fight.

This is an interesting way to try saying this :) It's the kind of thing you say to show off how well you write. I'm not actually sure my suggestion is permissible - it might need to be "against whom and against whose followers". It may be the best way to say it, I can't think of a formula that preserves all the meaning without being cumbersome. The closest I can get is "They try to fight against Voldemort and his followers, but throughout the series they experience his return." Not exactly the same emphasis, but something you can say without thinking so hard about it.

The wizarding world in both books and films gained lots of fans throughout the years and does not seem to be getting any less popular.


The wizarding world, in both books and films, gained lots of fans throughout the years, and does not seem to be getting any less popular.

"in both books and films" is again a dependent clause, and the other comma I put in because it just feels like an appropriate place for one. There's probably a rule about it.

Some people like books more because the story is more detailed.


Some people like the books more because the story is more detailed.

"Some people like books more" - books *in general*. Some people like books more, while others prefer films or TV. No specific books.

On the other hand, the films provide a lively experience.


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

Even though everybody has their preference, I can recommend both.


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

You need LangCorrect Premium to access this feature.

Go Premium